NHL

Rangers vs Lightning

Lightning expected to strike twice—yet the Blueshirts may dodge the big bolt.

New York Rangers

NYR (8-7-2) VS TBL (8-5-2)

Nov 12, 2025 | 7:00 PM ET | Benchmark International Arena, Tampa, FL

Tampa Bay Lightning
Moneyline Pick - Tampa Bay Lightning (-145): A-

Tampa Bay enters this matchup in sharp form, blending efficient offense with steady goaltending to remain one of the league’s hottest teams. Their top-six chemistry continues to drive consistent scoring, and special-teams play has steadily improved after a slow start. New York, while talented, arrives with lingering injuries that limit lineup cohesion and reduce depth down the middle. The Rangers’ travel schedule adds another hurdle against a Lightning group thriving at home. This prediction tilts toward Tampa maintaining momentum, as their structure and finishing edge make the moneyline bet at –145 a sound play.

From a betting perspective, this pick values current form and situational advantages. Tampa’s combination of high-end shot quality, active forecheck, and solid netminding offers a more reliable foundation than a visiting roster still integrating key pieces. Even with elite goaltending on the other side, sustained pressure and home-ice familiarity favor the hosts in a close but controlled contest. The Lightning’s balance and recent surge justify confidence at this price point.

This prediction gets an A– grade. Odds and availability subject to change. Follow Shurzy on Instagram and Tiktok for more expert picks.

Over/Under Pick - Under 6 (-115): B+

Both teams bring defensive sharpness and elite goaltending into this matchup, setting the stage for a tight, playoff-style pace. Tampa Bay’s structure has improved markedly during its current surge, anchored by disciplined special-teams play and reduced shot quality allowed. New York’s attack remains potent in spurts but has shown inconsistency at five-on-five, particularly on the road. With both netminders in rhythm and neither side eager to open lanes early, this prediction expects a controlled tempo that keeps scoring muted and supports an Under bet on the key number of six.

From a betting perspective, this pick hinges on sustained trends rather than outliers. Vasilevskiy and Shesterkin’s combined track record signals efficiency and minimal rebound chances, while both defenses are healthy enough to manage rush opportunities. Tampa’s recent penalty-kill surge and New York’s road scoring fluctuations further reinforce a conservative outlook. The total feels a touch high given these conditions, making the Under a logical and value-conscious selection.

This prediction gets a B+ grade. Odds and availability subject to change. Follow Shurzy on Instagram and Tiktok for more expert picks.

Puckline Pick - New York Rangers, +1.5 (-210): B

New York’s road form remains among the NHL’s most dependable, built on structured defense and timely goaltending that consistently keeps contests within a single score. The Rangers’ ability to neutralize speed and collapse efficiently in their own zone travels well, and with Shesterkin steady in net, they’re rarely out of striking distance. Tampa Bay’s recent wins have all come by razor-thin margins, a reflection of their methodical, low-variance style. This prediction points toward another close result defined by disciplined systems and minimal separation, making the +1.5 spread on New York a smart, correlation-friendly bet alongside the under lean.

From a betting lens, this pick targets probability and matchup rhythm rather than momentum. The Rangers’ combination of efficient puck exits and sturdy shot suppression gives them a high floor even against elite competition, while Tampa’s preference for controlled pace limits blowout risk. With both clubs comfortable grinding through one-goal finishes, backing New York with the cushion aligns with form and situational logic.

This prediction gets a B grade. Odds and availability subject to change. Follow Shurzy on Instagram and Tiktok for more expert picks.

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks