MLB

Cardinals vs Royals

Gateway gloves or Royal rally? Follow the value.

St. Louis Cardinals

Cardinals (24-20) VS Royals (25-20)

May 17, 2025 | 7:10 p.m. ET | Kauffman Stadium, Kansas City

Kansas City Royals
Moneyline Pick - St. Louis Cardinals (+105): B+

The visiting squad arrives on the back of a brief offensive lull, while the home team rides a solid win streak built on strong starting pitching and a resurgent middle of the lineup. Injuries have thinned the bullpen depth for the visitors, making it tougher to navigate late-inning pressure, especially against an opponent that has historically hit them well. The home team's lineup has found rhythm this month, and their ability to hold leads late—thanks to a reliable back-end relief corps—adds further confidence.

With current form, matchup trends, and roster health leaning heavily toward the home side, the market’s slight underdog status for them looks like a value opportunity. Backing the home team earns a B+ grade—a smart bet with solid probability and favorable price.

Over/Under Pick - Under 8.5 (-110): B

One team enters riding the momentum of a multi-game win streak, while the other looks to snap a brief skid. Both lineups are operating without key middle-order bats, which puts even more pressure on a matchup between two strong starters—one a seasoned veteran with dominant recent form, the other a young southpaw thriving in his home park. With both offenses thinned and each bullpen ranking among the league's most efficient over the last two weeks, scoring opportunities should be scarce.

Given the arms on the mound and the current offensive limitations, this sets up as a tightly contested, low-scoring affair. The under looks like the best value on the board, with a total that could easily stay beneath nine runs if either starter controls the early innings. This play earns a B grade for its combination of probability, game flow logic, and market value.

Spread Pick - St. Louis Cardinals, +1.5 (-195): B

A surging visiting team rolls into this regional matchup with recent momentum on its side, while the home club looks to rebound from back-to-back losses. That contrast, coupled with a bullpen that has been one of the more reliable units over the past week, provides some late-game insurance for the road team—especially as the hosts may be without one of their key run producers. Meanwhile, the visitors’ veteran bats have historically thrived in this matchup, and the home starter has shown occasional control issues that could lead to extra baserunners.

Scoring may come in small doses given lineup injuries on both sides, but the run line offers enough wiggle room to back the steadier, better-performing club. It’s not a discount play, but there’s solid logic and recent trend backing behind it. Grade: B, with dependable value on the visiting side keeping it within a run—or winning outright.

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks