MLB

Mariners vs Athletics

Pacific pulse favors the visitors—expect Seattle’s arms to sing.

Seattle Mariners

Mariners (20-12) VS Athletics (18-16)

05/05/2025 | 10:05 PM ET | Oakland Coliseum, Oakland, CA

Athletics
Moneyline Pick - Seattle Mariners (-115): B

Seattle enters this divisional tilt in strong form, carrying a multi-game win streak that reflects both lineup depth and a sturdy rotation. Their projected starter tonight matches up favorably against an Oakland team that has dropped back-to-back games and continues to work through roster absences in both the infield and bullpen. The road team’s lineup has historically performed well against left-handed pitching, and their bullpen—though not without its own adjustments—has remained effective at protecting leads.

Oakland, by contrast, faces challenges on multiple fronts: rotational uncertainty, diminished late-inning reliability, and some thinned offensive production. With both clubs entering the second quarter of the season, the difference in run differential and recent execution suggests a clear edge for the visitors. Backing Seattle at a modest price earns a solid “B” grade—a balanced blend of momentum, matchup strength, and value.

Over/Under Pick - Under 9, (-110): B+

Seattle and Athletics square off with both teams leaning more on pitching than power in recent games. While the Mariners carry modest momentum, the Athletics have cooled off with a couple of setbacks, and each club continues to navigate lineup absences and scoring inconsistency. With high-strikeout starters on both sides and bullpen arms capable of limiting late-inning damage, consistent offense may be hard to come by.

The history between these division rivals also supports a low-scoring narrative—recent meetings have stayed under the total, and neither team enters with a lineup clicking on all cylinders. Add in a pitcher-friendly setting and a run line that may slightly overestimate current form, and the Under looks like a strong “B+” play, backed by form trends and matchup dynamics.

Spread Pick - Seattle Mariners, -1.5 (+140): B

Seattle enters this matchup on a strong run, while Athletics continues to search for consistency following a string of recent losses. The visiting club benefits from a rested starting arm with a solid track record in this ballpark, and their bullpen remains one of the most efficient in the league. On the other side, the home team is dealing with key absences in both the lineup and relief corps, and their rotation plans have been shuffled due to an untimely setback.

With early-season divisional positioning in play and a significant edge in both depth and recent form, the visiting side appears well-positioned to control the game’s tempo. Add in a favorable pitching matchup and a plus return on the run line, and the play grades out as a dependable “B”—solid value for bettors willing to trust the better-rounded roster.

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks