MLB

Giants vs Phillies

A high-stakes showdown awaits in the City of Brotherly Love

San Francisco Giants

GIants (12-5) VS Phillies (10-7)

Apr 17, 2025 | 16:05 ET | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Philadelphia Phillies
Moneyline Pick - Philadelphia Phillies (-178): B+

The Philadelphia Phillies aim to halt their recent slide behind a strong offense that historically excels against San Francisco Giants pitching, while the Giants enter the matchup riding a win despite missing key pieces from their lineup. Given Philadelphia's home advantage, healthier roster, and proven track record in this matchup, the Phillies appear well-positioned to win, earning a solid recommendation.

Honestly, Philly feels like the right play today. Sure, the Giants are hot, but the Phillies usually handle their pitching pretty well, and being at home with fewer injury concerns makes them tough to bet against here.

Over/Under Pick - Over 8, (-110): B

The San Francisco Giants send a reliable starter to the mound, looking to continue their current winning streak against a Philadelphia Phillies team dealing with injury questions around a key hitter. Still, historical trends suggest these lineups consistently produce runs when matched up, hinting at a high-scoring affair. Both teams have started the season strong, and offensive fireworks appear likely, making the Over bet appealing with moderate confidence.

This feels like one of those games where pitching won't keep the bats quiet. Even with some uncertainty around the Phillies' lineup, these teams tend to rack up runs, so I'd definitely be leaning toward the Over in this matchup.

Spread Pick - Giants, +1.5 (-145): B+

The San Francisco Giants enter this matchup with their ace on the mound, well-positioned to contain a Philadelphia Phillies lineup battling through inconsistencies and health issues. Philadelphia's recent struggles suggest limited offensive potential, which gives the Giants, despite their own roster absences, an edge thanks to superior pitching and clutch hitting. Expect San Francisco to cover with confidence.

I'd definitely back the Giants here—they've got the momentum and the better pitcher. Philly just doesn't seem sharp right now, and this matchup clearly favors San Francisco covering the spread.

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks