MLB

Pirates vs Phillies

Heavy bats and home comfort tilt the scales in Philly

Pittsburgh Pirates

Pirates (15-29) VS Phillies (25-18)

May 17, 2025 | 6:05 PM ET | Citizens Bank Park

Philadelphia Phillies
Moneyline Pick - Philadelphia Phillies (-292): B

Philadelphia enters this matchup with a strong starting arm on a winning streak and a bullpen that’s recently been bolstered, while Pittsburgh rolls in with a lineup struggling to generate consistent run support. The visitors remain shorthanded in the late innings, and their reliance on younger arms in high-leverage spots could prove costly against a patient and powerful offense at home.

Even with the price leaning chalk-heavy, the situational edge—stronger rotation, more reliable bullpen, and home-field momentum—makes backing the hosts a reasonable play. The payout might not be flashy, but the probability is high enough to earn a B grade for value with minimal risk.

Over/Under Pick - Over 8, (-110): B

One team enters this interleague clash on a hot streak at the plate, while the other struggles to stop the bleeding after a string of tough losses that has stretched a thin bullpen even further. With both starting pitchers heading in different recent directions—one steady, one leaking power—the early innings could tilt toward action, especially in a park known for favoring hitters during warm spring evenings.

Neither lineup is at full strength, but both still bring enough punch to challenge middle relief if the starters don’t go deep. Given the recent scoring trends and the likelihood of bullpen exposure before the ninth, the total leans high. The Over earns a B-grade, pairing solid situational angles with moderate juice for a reasonably confident play.

Spread Pick - Pittsburgh Pirates, +1.5 (-115): B

Despite a strong stretch from the home side, offensive depth remains a concern with key contributors missing and rotation shuffles continuing. The visitors, though riding a losing streak, bring a well-rested starter with a solid track record against this opponent and a bullpen that has consistently kept games close—even in defeat.

Given recent trends that show a tendency toward one-run outcomes and the host’s less-than-dominant record in tight contests, grabbing the run and a half offers solid value. This play earns a B grade for its balance of risk and potential payout, especially with the underdog’s ability to hang around late into games.

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks