MLB

Phillies vs Athletics

East Coast thunder looks to roll through the Bay breeze

Philadelphia Phillies

Phillies (32-18) VS Athletics (22-29)

24 May 2025 | 10:05 p.m. ET | Oakland Coliseum

Athletics
Moneyline Pick - Philadelphia Phillies (-170): B

One club rolls into the weekend riding a strong multi-game win streak and gaining reinforcements, while the hosts continue to shuffle lineups amid absences and recent struggles. The visiting rotation lines up favorably behind its top arm, who previously dominated in this venue earlier in the season, and the offense benefits from a strong historical trend in these interleague matchups. In contrast, the home squad has scuffled at the plate and continues to seek consistency from the back half of its order.

With momentum, rotation strength, and bullpen rest all leaning the visitors' way, even a slightly juiced moneyline feels justified. It’s not quite postseason urgency yet, but with standings starting to matter and one side showing clear direction, this shapes up as a value-backed play. Grade: B for above-average confidence and a price worth the ticket.

Over/Under Pick - Under 9.5 (-110): B

A visiting ace brings strong recent form into a matchup with a slumping home squad that has lost offensive punch due to a key absence in the middle infield. The road team, while carrying solid momentum, isn’t at full strength themselves, and the ballpark's spacious dimensions paired with cool night conditions should suppress scoring. Both rotations feature starters with favorable matchups, and recent bullpen usage suggests fresh relief arms will be ready to keep things quiet late.

While both lineups have their share of power, the combination of pitching matchups, park factors, and lineup attrition all point to a lower-scoring affair. The under on a 9.5 total presents respectable value and earns a confident B grade—supported by trends, setting, and situational edges that tilt toward a modest scoreboard.

Spread Pick - Philadelphia Phillies, -1.5 (-110): B+

A surging road team heads into the Bay Area with key players mostly intact and recent success fueling their confidence. The home side, meanwhile, is grappling with injuries to important pieces both in the field and in the bullpen, contributing to a losing streak that underscores their current struggles. On the mound, the visitors send a rested and effective starter who has historically handled this opponent well, while the home club counters with a left-hander who has shown some vulnerability to power bats from both sides of the plate.

With playoff positioning already on the visitors’ radar and the hosts more focused on development and consistency, the edge is clear. The combination of superior form, roster health, and pitching matchups makes backing the road club on the -1.5 run line a strong play. Grade: B for dependable value with reasonable risk.

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks