MLB

Phillies vs Athletics

East Coast thunder looks to drown West Coast underdogs

Philadelphia Phillies

Phillies (31-18) VS Athletics (22-28)

May 23 2025 | 10:05 p.m. ET | Sutter Health Park

Athletics
Moneyline Pick – Philadelphia Phillies (-190): B

Philadelphia enters this matchup riding seven straight wins, while the Athletics are struggling to break out of their recent nine game skid. The Phillies hold the advantage of a healthier roster and a more consistent lineup, especially when facing right-handed pitching, and their starting pitcher has a track record of shutting down this opponent. Meanwhile, the A’s continue to deal with key bullpen absences and have struggled to get on base this month, making it tough to find much upside for the home side.

Honestly, the Phillies just look like the better option, as the all around hotter team, with better pitching, and fewer injuries. Even if the odds aren’t a steal, it’s a solid value play with how these two clubs are trending right now.

Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 23/05/2025 09:53

Over/Under Pick - Under 9.5, (-108): B

Philadelphia comes in riding high, but this matchup looks like it could be more of a pitchers’ duel than their recent games suggest. The Phillies’ starter has been excellent at inducing ground balls, and the Athletics’ offense has struggled to generate much power, especially with a key bat still sidelined. The A's starter has also had some quiet success against Philadelphia’s top hitters, and both teams will have their best relievers ready to close things out in a pitcher-friendly environment.

Honestly, even with the Phillies’ momentum, the setup points to a low-scoring game. The under looks like a smart play here—both starters can keep hitters in check, and the conditions favor pitching over offense tonight.

Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 23/05/2025 09:53

Spread Pick - Philadelphia Phillies, -1.5 (-110): B

Philadelphia rolls into this game with a hot streak and a lineup that’s getting healthier, while the Athletics continue to search for answers both in the rotation and at the plate. The Phillies’ starter has held this lineup in check before, and the bullpen has the depth to handle any late-game pressure, especially with the Athletics monitoring their closer’s workload. On offense, Philadelphia has enough firepower to take advantage of a depleted A’s staff and a lineup that’s had trouble stringing hits together against right-handed pitching.

Honestly, taking Philadelphia to cover the run line feels like the right move here. The matchup tilts their way across the board, and with the way they’re playing, it’s a value play that makes sense—even if it isn’t a complete no-brainer with some travel and weather factors.

Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 23/05/2025 09:54

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks