Yankees vs Rays
Can the Bombers extend their roll while the Rays wobble?

Yankees (11-7) VS Rays (8-10)
Apr 18, 2025 | 7:05 p.m. ET | Yankee Stadium, Bronx

New York enters this divisional clash on the upswing, while Tampa Bay is still trying to find its footing amid a brief skid and a few key absences. The Yankees have found rotation stability despite early injuries and are leaning on a bullpen that’s been among the league’s best so far. The Rays, meanwhile, are turning to an opener strategy that has yielded mixed results, and their offense has cooled off against New York’s pitching in recent matchups. With both teams at even odds, the more complete and settled side gets the nod.
If you’re eyeing a side here, backing the Yankees makes sense. They’ve got more momentum, a healthier lineup, and a bullpen that’s been consistently locking down games. The Rays can always piece together wins, but given the current form and pitching plans, the edge leans toward New York. At pick’em value, it’s a smart lean with a solid foundation behind it.
New York enters this series with momentum, while Tampa Bay arrives on the heels of a short skid and a bullpen still dealing with injury and overuse. Both teams are navigating rotation absences, but the matchup on the mound points to potential early offense on both sides, especially with familiar hitter-pitcher histories favoring several key bats. The Yankees continue to generate hard contact at one of the highest rates in the league, and the Rays remain a strong road-hitting team, making for a setup that leans toward run production.
If you're looking at the total, the Over makes a lot of sense here. With warm weather, power-loaded lineups, and two starters who have struggled in past matchups against key hitters, there’s reason to expect runs early and often. Both bullpens may settle things late, but this has all the makings of a game that pushes the scoreboard early—making the Over a solid play.
New York returns home looking to snap a short slide, but Tampa Bay arrives with momentum and a bit more stability on both sides of the ball. The Yankees continue to deal with rotation and bullpen injuries, relying on less experienced arms to keep pace against a Rays team that has been getting strong performances from both its starters and relievers. While the Bronx bats remain dangerous, Tampa’s ability to shorten games with a high-performing bullpen could be the difference in a tight contest.
From a betting angle, taking the Rays with the run feels like the smarter play. They’re in better current form, getting solid production from their lineup against right-handed pitching, and have the edge in late-game reliability. Even if the Yankees strike early, the cushion of a run combined with Tampa’s recent surge gives the visitors solid value here. It's not flashy, but it’s the kind of underdog cover that can quietly cash.
.png)
Get the best odds on this prediction
Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks
Related posts
Check out the latest picks from Shurzy AI and our team of experts.