MLB

Yankees vs Guardians

Bats boom, drums fade—one side keeps rolling in The Land

New York Yankees

Yankees (14-8) VS Guardians (12-9)

Apr 21 2025 | 6:10 PM ET | Progressive Field, Cleveland

Cleveland Guardians
Moneyline Pick ‑ Yankees (-120): A‑ 

New York’s recent uptick in form—bolstered by solid road hitting and a deep lineup—is well-timed as they head into a series against a Cleveland squad that’s struggled to close games. The Yankees enter on a great form and send a somewhat reliable arm to the mound, with a strong historical track record against Cleveland. In contrast, the Guardians are starting a young right-hander who has struggled at the major league level since his fine rookie season. That mismatch could tilt things further in favor of New York, which currently holds the best run differential in the American League.

Even with a couple of minor health concerns in the lineup, the Yankees have enough offensive balance—particularly against right-handed pitching—to take advantage of a Cleveland bullpen that’s been among the league’s most vulnerable in recent weeks. With momentum on their side and a clear edge on the mound, backing New York at modest odds looks like a smart play. This one gets an A-grade for confidence.

Over/Under Pick - Under 8.5 (-115): B

New York enters this one riding a 7-3 run behind strong starting pitching, while Cleveland, dealing with the absence of their ace, turns to a young but fairly capable right-hander. Despite offensive firepower on both sides, recent trends suggest this pitching matchup has favored strikeouts over slugfests. The key bats on each team have historically underperformed in this head-to-head scenario, and both bullpens currently rank among the league’s best in ERA, adding further weight to a low-scoring outlook.

Even with favorable weather conditions for hitters, the combination of effective arms and cooler bats gives this game a strong Under profile. At a line of 8.5, this total feels a touch high given the way both teams are set up right now. The Under is the sharper side here, and it earns a solid A-grade in confidence.

Spread Pick - New York Yankees, -1.5 (-140): B

New York looks to start another winning streak as they visit Cleveland, while the Guardians hope to build on a modest pair of wins despite key injuries in their lineup. With the Yankees turning to a reliable arm and Cleveland relying on a starter tasked with neutralizing a deep and dangerous order, the matchup heavily tilts toward the visitors. Cleveland’s ongoing struggles against high-velocity right-handers and New York’s well-rested bullpen support a scenario where momentum could swing early and stay there.

Given the disparity in offensive firepower and the pitching edge, backing New York on the minus-1.5 run line makes sense here. The visiting side has the tools and depth to stretch this one out, especially if the opposing bats continue to slump. This run line pick gets an A-grade for confidence.

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks