NHL

New York Rangers vs New York Islanders

An edge on the Island: Isles push for playoff life

New York Rangers

New York Rangers (36-34-7) VS Sparky the Dragon (34-32-11)

April 10, 2025 | 6:30 PM ET | UBS Arena

New York Islanders
Moneyline Pick: New York Islanders (-120): Grade B

The Isles are rallying when it matters most. Riding a three-game win streak into the final stretch of the regular season, the New York Islanders are clinging to their playoff hopes, while the Blueshirts are sputtering, losing four of their last five contests. Compounding the Rangers' woes, Chris Kreider is questionable for tonight’s tilt due to a lower-body injury, and his absence could hobble their first power play unit, especially with Artemi Panarin slumping. Meanwhile, Islanders netminder Ilya Sorokin has been stellar against the Rangers historically, boasting a .935 save percentage in five previous starts. The Long Island squad has found its rhythm offensively. Factor in home-ice advantage at UBS Arena and you’ve got the makings of a critical victory for the Isles as they chase the final wildcard spot. Given the playoff implications, recent form, and the moneyline value relative to risk, this prediction is rated a cautious but solid Grade B. Recommend betting the Islanders straight on the moneyline at -120 for mild value with postseason motivation behind them. Odds and availability are subject to change.

Over/Under Pick: Under 5.5, (-115) - Grade: B

The Islanders look to halt a two-game skid against their Manhattan rivals with hopes of inching closer to a wild card spot, while the Blueshirts—riding a modest three-game win streak—aim to secure postseason breathing room of their own. Defense may dominate this latest chapter of their bitter rivalry. Meanwhile, Igor Shesterkin has posted a 1.98 GAA in his last five starts against the Isles, and his netminding could be the difference-maker again against a team that's struggled to create consistent looks. On the other side, Ilya Sorokin has also stymied the Rangers in past matchups, boasting a .927 save percentage against the Blueshirts. With both squads aware that a single point matters at this stage of the season, expect a more conservative, grind-it-out affair, especially with each team averaging under 3 goals per game over the past two weeks. Though the line sits at 5.5, the combination of recent trends, playoff tension, and top-tier goaltending makes the under an appealing lean.  


Puckline Pick: New York Islanders, +1.5 (-205) - Grade: B

The Isles are quietly catching fire. With points in six of their last seven games, the New York Islanders have hit their stride just when it matters most. Meanwhile, the Broadway Blueshirts have dropped three straight and are battling inconsistency with Igor Shesterkin showing signs of fatigue down the stretch. Though Artemi Panarin remains a dynamo for the Rangers, the Islanders' top line—anchored by Mathew Barzal and—has historically performed well in this crosstown clash, particularly at UBS Arena. Both teams are clinging to slim wildcard hopes, adding playoff desperation to their already heated rivalry. Injuries to key Rangers defenseman K’Andre Miller and forward Blake Wheeler tilt the balance slightly toward the home team maintaining tight score lines. Given New York's (Rangers) heavy juice at -250 on the puckline, the value play lies with the gritty Isles keeping this close—or even pulling out a scrappy win. With a solid chance of cashing but limited payout, this pick lands at a B.  

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks