MLB

Astros vs Brewers

Southpaw in control? Look for Space City to silence the suds.

Houston Astros

Astros (17-15) VS Brewers (16-18)

05/05/2025 | 7:40 PM ET | American Family Field, Milwaukee

Milwaukee Brewers
Moneyline Pick ‑ Houston Astros (-105): B

Houston heads into this road matchup on the upswing, pairing a solid recent stretch of offensive production with a starting pitcher who thrives on soft contact and pitch efficiency. The visiting bullpen has stabilized lately and comes in fresher and more complete than Milwaukee’s, which remains short key late-inning arms. Meanwhile, the home team’s rotation option for tonight has historically struggled in this matchup type and may be asked to go deeper than ideal due to thin relief support.

With the visitors fielding a full-strength lineup and entering in sharper form, the slight edge in both mound depth and lineup protection becomes hard to ignore—especially at a nearly even-money price point. It’s not a high-upside smash, but with better health, more stability, and recent trends leaning their way, taking Houston here earns a solid “B” grade for both probability and value.

Over/Under Pick - Under 8, (-105): B

Milwaukee enters this matchup looking to break out of a recent slump, while Houston arrives with a touch more momentum and a rested bullpen. Both teams face depth concerns in the heart of their lineups, as key contributors remain either sidelined or at less than full strength, reducing the likelihood of early scoring outbursts. With strong recent form from both starting pitchers and lineups showing signs of inconsistency, the game projects as a low-event grind.

The ballpark’s conditions—particularly early-season roof closures—tend to suppress flight and favor pitching. Combine that with the playoff-tinged urgency of two clubs hovering near .500 in competitive divisions, and neither side is likely to stretch its bullpen thin chasing early offense. The Under 8 earns a solid “B” grade—plenty of justification via matchup and setting, though power bats always make it a bit of a sweat late.

Spread Pick - Milwaukee Brewers, +1.5 (-190): B-

Milwaukee enters this home tilt showing signs of offensive rhythm, while Houston continues to navigate rotation uncertainty and bullpen wear. The visiting side leans on a starter who has struggled with efficiency against this lineup profile in past meetings, and their relievers are operating on heavy recent workloads. Conversely, the home team enjoys a relatively healthy roster, dependable late-inning arms, and a strong track record of keeping games tight in their own park. With both clubs hovering near the middle of their division standings, the margin for error feels especially slim.

Look, this isn’t about expecting a blowout—it’s about reading the situation. The home side tends to punch above its weight in one-run games, especially when bullpen matchups lean in their favor late. With home-field energy and historical matchup trends offering added confidence, grabbing the +1.5 cushion makes plenty of sense here. It’s a “B” grade play—reliable, steady, and well-aligned with the kind of game script both teams are likely to deliver.

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks