NFL
Eagles vs Bills
Cold rain, colder defense: Buffalo leans on December dominance.

Philadelphia Eagles
PHI (10-5) VS BUF (11-4)
December 28, 2025 | 4:25 PM ET | Highmark Stadium, Orchard Park, NY

Buffalo Bills

Moneyline Pick - Buffalo Bills (-125): A-
With Buffalo riding a four-game win streak and an elite recent December track record, especially at home, while Philadelphia arrives on a two-game rebound but already having clinched the NFC East, the situational edge tilts toward the Bills on the moneyline at -125 in this Orchard Park cold and rain. Josh Allen’s sore foot and “day-to-day” tag are worth monitoring, yet he’s expected to start and continue a durability run that spans 120 straight starts, and the Bills have historically played some of their best football in this month under his leadership. On the Eagles’ side, A.J. Brown’s midweek wisdom-tooth procedure plus the uncertainty around Lane Johnson and linebacker Nakobe Dean—offset somewhat by Jalen Carter’s anticipated return—creates just enough instability around Jalen Hurts to matter against a Buffalo team still pushing hard for AFC East positioning rather than merely coasting on a clinched berth. Given the Bills’ dominant recent December profile at Highmark Stadium, home-field advantage in messy weather, and the higher urgency level, I’m backing Buffalo on the moneyline and grading this as an A- pick for both win probability and pricing relative to their current form. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 26/12/2025 11:57
Over/Under Pick - Under 44, (-110): B+
The combination of a cold, rainy forecast in an open-air Highmark Stadium, a healthier Eagles defensive front with Jalen Carter back in the fold, and a Bills offense managing multiple bumps and bruises (including Allen’s foot and a lengthy defensive injury list) all lean toward a slightly compressed scoring environment relative to a 44-point total. Buffalo has been comfortable winning lower-possession December games at home, and Philadelphia’s offense—while dangerous with Hurts and Brown—may lean more on Saquon Barkley and a physical ground approach if Brown isn’t at full strength and the right tackle situation remains unsettled, especially on a slick field. Allen has historically moved the ball on this defense, but in these conditions, drives are likelier to bog down into field goals and fourth-down decisions rather than consistent chunk plays, and both teams have playoff spots secured enough that neither needs to empty the playbook in the elements. That combination of weather, trench play, and slightly compromised skill groups on both sides nudges me to the Under 44 at -110, which I’ll grade as a B+ given the matchup fit but the ever-present explosive upside of two top-tier quarterbacks. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 26/12/2025 11:57
Spread Pick - Buffalo Bills, -1.5 (-105): B
With the spread sitting at Bills -1.5, the point spread essentially asks whether Buffalo can convert its December dominance and four-game surge into a straightforward home win by more than a point, and I think the combination of Allen’s track record against the Eagles, the Bills’ 10-1 home mark in December over recent seasons, and their stronger immediate incentive in the AFC East race makes that a reasonable expectation. Philadelphia’s clinched-division status, the uncertainty at linebacker with Nakobe Dean “iffy,” and the possibility that Lane Johnson remains sidelined while the defense leans on Carter’s return all suggest slight volatility in their week-to-week performance level, particularly in a hostile, wet road environment. Allen’s prior production versus this opponent, plus Buffalo’s historical ability to close tight December games at Highmark, tips me toward laying the short number instead of taking the plus-money Eagles side, though the overlap with the moneyline and volatility from the injury situations keeps this a B-grade rather than elite value. I’ll lay the -1.5 with Buffalo at -105 and look for a field-goal-or-better margin. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 26/12/2025 11:57
Get the best odds on this prediction
Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks
Related posts
Check out the latest picks from Shurzy AI and our team of experts.
