NHL

Senators vs Rangers

Brady Tkachuk’s scoring touch meets a desperate Rangers blue line at the Garden.

Ottawa Senators

OTT (36-24-9) VS NYR (28-33-8)

March 23, 2026 | 7:30 PM ET | Madison Square Garden, New York, NY

New York Rangers
Moneyline Pick - Ottawa Senators (-179): B
Ottawa rolls into MSG on a three-game winning streak while New York has dropped three straight, and that recent divergence in form matters with the Senators chasing wild-card security and the Rangers clinging to faint playoff hopes. Ottawa’s blue line is banged up with Jake Sanderson, Nick Jensen and Dennis Gilbert all out, but their forward core of Brady Tkachuk, Tim Stützle, Drake Batherson and Claude Giroux is intact and driving a top-tier attack against a Rangers group that has leaked goals all month. Tkachuk has already torched New York this season with a four-point night in the 8–4 win at the Garden, and he’s been a consistent problem for the Blueshirts going back to last year’s overtime winner, while Mika Zibanejad and Adam Fox haven’t been able to cover for a thin Rangers depth chart and a shaky home record. With Ottawa owning a clear 5-on-5 edge, recent head-to-head success and the rest advantage against a Rangers team that’s been sagging defensively, the Senators moneyline is the side, but at -179 the price bakes in much of that edge, so I grade it a B for solid likelihood with only moderate value. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 23/03/2026 09:20
Over/Under Pick - Over 6, (-101): B+
The Senators enter on a run of four wins in their last five and have scored at least five goals in three straight, while the Rangers’ recent three-game losing streak has featured 16 goals against, signaling defensive slippage that could continue on home ice. Ottawa’s blue line is missing key minute-eater Jake Sanderson along with depth pieces Nick Jensen and Dennis Gilbert, which raises the ceiling on chances against even if Linus Ullmark or James Reimer holds up reasonably well, and New York’s best path to hang around is to lean on Mika Zibanejad, Vincent Trocheck and Alexis Lafrenière to trade chances rather than grind out a low-event game. Every meeting between these teams over the last two seasons has hit at least six goals, including this year’s 8–4 Senators win at MSG and last year’s 4–3 Ottawa overtime victory, and with Ottawa averaging well north of three goals per game and the Rangers sitting underwater in goal differential, the offensive environment points more toward a 4–3 type scoreboard than a 3–2 grind. Layer in the playoff urgency on Ottawa’s side and the fact that New York still has high-end skill up front despite its record, and Over 6 at -101 offers a slight pricing edge with strong correlation to how both teams are playing, earning a B+ grade. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 23/03/2026 09:20
Puckline Pick - Ottawa Senators, -1.5 (134): B-
Given Ottawa’s three-game heater and New York’s three-game skid, the Senators’ recent results suggest they’re more likely to pull away than the records alone imply, especially with the Rangers’ confidence shaken and their playoff hopes nearly extinguished compared to Ottawa’s tight grip on a wild-card spot. The big caveat is Ottawa’s injury-hit defense—Jake Sanderson, Nick Jensen and Dennis Gilbert are all out—which introduces extra volatility but also increases the chance of an up-tempo game where Ottawa’s superior forward depth can create separation, particularly if Brady Tkachuk and Tim Stützle again exploit a Rangers back end that has struggled to protect whichever goalie (Igor Shesterkin or Jonathan Quick) is in the crease. Tkachuk’s history of multi-point outbursts against New York, including the 8–4 beatdown at MSG earlier this season, shows the Sens have already demonstrated blowout potential in this matchup, and New York’s poor home record combined with their negative goal differential suggests that when they lose, they often lose by margin. At +134 on the -1.5 puckline, you’re trading a decent amount of win probability for significantly better payout than the moneyline, so while the Senators’ superior form and matchup justify the swing for a larger score, the inherent variance in covering the number keeps this at a B- grade. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 23/03/2026 09:20
Not sure which game to try next? Let Piggy Arcade’s AI recommendations guide you to your next favourite demo.
Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks