NBA

Magic vs Pacers

Magic’s rising core looks to deepen Indy’s midwinter slide.

Orlando Magic

Magic (18-15) VS Pacers (6-27)

December 31, 2025 | 3:00 PM ET | Gainbridge Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN

Indiana Pacers
Moneyline Pick - Orlando Magic (-165): B+
Orlando leans on Paolo Banchero as it rolls into Indianapolis having played roughly .500 basketball over its last several outings, while Indiana staggers in on a nine-game losing streak and a 6-27 mark that reflects how hard the post-Haliburton era has hit them. The Magic are dealing with their own issues — Franz and Moritz Wagner are out and Jonathan Isaac, Jalen Suggs, and Desmond Bane are all on the injury report — but the Pacers’ injury sheet is even uglier, with Tyrese Haliburton ruled out for the entire season and frontcourt pieces like Obi Toppin and Isaiah Jackson unavailable plus backcourt depth concerns around Ben Sheppard and T.J. McConnell. Historically, Banchero has shredded this matchup (around 28 points, 6 boards, and 4 assists in six career games against Indiana, including a 50-point eruption), while Pascal Siakam has been productive but more in line with his typical 20-6-4 profile against Orlando’s length, and over 33 games the Magic’s more balanced rotation and superior defense give them a clear edge despite the road setting and injuries. I’m taking Orlando on the moneyline at -165 with a B+ grade: strong directional lean toward the Magic with solid win probability, but the juice trims the overall value. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 31/12/2025 09:39
Over/Under Pick - Over 225.5 (-110): B
Indiana’s recent results scream pace and defensive frailty, with its last three losses (to Boston, Miami, and Houston) all sailing well north of 240 combined points as Siakam, Bennedict Mathurin, and Andrew Nembhard carry a high-usage, turnover-prone offense on a roster ravaged by injuries to Tyrese Haliburton, Obi Toppin, Isaiah Jackson, and others. Orlando’s overall profile under Jamahl Mosley has been more defensive, but this year’s version mixes that with real scoring pop from Banchero, Desmond Bane, Anthony Black, and Wendell Carter Jr., and recent totals in the 210–250 range suggest that even with Franz Wagner and Moritz Wagner sidelined and Isaac/Suggs/Bane banged up, the Magic can still exploit the Pacers’ soft interior and transition defense. With Indiana’s nine-game skid pushing Rick Carlisle to lean on faster lineups and Orlando’s offensive talent historically giving this matchup problems, I expect enough possessions and free throws to clear 225.5, so I’ll play Over 225.5 at -110 with a B grade: respectable edge fueled by pace and matchup-driven scoring, but injury volatility on Orlando’s side keeps it shy of elite confidence. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 31/12/2025 09:39
Spread Pick - Orlando Magic, -3.5 (-115): B-
Pascal Siakam is doing everything he can to keep Indiana competitive, but over this nine-game losing streak the Pacers have routinely fallen by multiple possessions, and without Haliburton, Toppin, Jackson, and other depth pieces they’re forced into lineups that bleed points and struggle to generate efficient halfcourt offense against longer, switchable defenses like Orlando’s. Even with the Magic’s injury list — Franz and Moritz Wagner out, Isaac/Suggs/Bane in varying states of questionable — they can still roll out a bigger, deeper top eight featuring Banchero, Carter Jr., Bane, Black, and Jalen Suggs (if he’s cleared), which has already handled similar or better opponents by comfortable margins during this 18-15 start. Given Banchero’s history of big nights against the Pacers and the combination of Orlando’s size advantage and Indiana’s reliance on Siakam and streaky perimeter shooting to keep games close, I’m willing to lay the short number and back the Magic -3.5 at -115 with a B- grade: I expect Orlando to win and cover more often than not, but the road spot, their own injury questions, and late backdoor risk keep this squarely in medium-confidence territory. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 31/12/2025 09:39
Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks