NHL
Rangers vs Flyers
Two desperate Metro rivals, one chance to stop the slide.

New York Rangers
NYR (20-22-6) VS PHI (22-16-8)
January 17, 2026 | 1:00 PM ET | Xfinity Mobile Arena, Philadelphia, PA

Philadelphia Flyers

Moneyline Pick - Philadelphia Flyers (-143): B
Both teams limp into this one on five-game losing streaks, but the way they’re losing matters for the moneyline: the Rangers have been shelled for 10, 4, and 8 goals in their last three outings, while the Flyers have bled 25 goals over their five-game slide, much of that tied to special-teams breakdowns rather than five-on-five play. With Igor Shesterkin and Adam Fox both ruled out, plus depth pieces like Conor Sheary and Adam Edstrom sidelined, New York is missing its true No. 1 goalie and elite puck-moving defenseman, forcing Jonathan Quick and an overtaxed blue line to handle heavy minutes; Philadelphia’s injury list (Dan Vladar, Rasmus Ristolainen, Bobby Brink, Tyson Foerster) hurts, but their core of Travis Konecny, Sean Couturier, and Trevor Zegras remains intact. Historically, Panarin and Mika Zibanejad have torched the Flyers, from Panarin’s multi-goal and shootout-winner performance in the 5-4 Rangers victory on December 20 to Zibanejad’s famous back-to-back hat trick blowouts earlier in his career, while Konecny has piled up points across dozens of games vs New York, so the individual star power is largely balanced. The difference for this bet is venue and current roster health: a Flyers group that still drives better five-on-five shot share at home, facing a Rangers team whose recent defensive collapses have coincided almost perfectly with Fox and Shesterkin leaving the lineup, in a game that matters for Philadelphia’s hold on a playoff spot and New York’s hope of climbing back into the mix after the season’s midpoint. Laying -143 on a slumping favorite is never comfortable, but with home ice, the healthier spine, and New York’s goaltending downgrade, I like the Flyers to grind out a regulation or OT win often enough to justify a grade of B on this moneyline—reasonable edge and solid upside, but recent volatility and the Rangers’ dangerous power play keep it short of A territory. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 17/01/2026 09:25
Over/Under Pick - Over 6, (-133): B-
Given that both teams are on five-game losing streaks largely driven by defensive meltdowns, the total of 6 with over juice at -133 looks aggressive but justified: New York has recently surrendered double digits to Boston and eight goals to Ottawa, while Philadelphia has allowed 23 goals in its last four games and is getting carved up on the penalty kill, which has yielded a dozen power-play goals over the past eight contests. The Rangers’ power play has been one of the few bright spots at around a 22 percent conversion rate, and they’ve already hung five on the Flyers in a 5-4 shootout win this season, with Panarin doing most of the damage; that’s a bad matchup for a Flyers PK that has sprung leaks everywhere and is now leaning on a tandem of Samuel Ersson and Aleksei Kolosov while Vladar recovers. On the other side, even with Shesterkin out, the Rangers’ patchwork defense and Quick–Martin duo have struggled to manage rush chances and backdoor plays, exactly the type of looks Konecny, Zegras, Michkov, and Tippett can generate off the cycle and in transition, and the Flyers have quietly averaged close to three goals per game despite their recent slump. Add in rivalry intensity, meaningful playoff implications for both teams beyond the halfway mark, and the tendency for Rangers–Flyers games to tilt into track meets when special teams get involved, and a 4-3 or 5-3 type score feels more likely than a tight 3-2 grind, even in a daytime start; I’ll go Over 6 at -133 with a B- grade, acknowledging that the number and juice eat into the value and that a rare goaltending bounce-back on either side could drag this to a push or narrow under. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 17/01/2026 09:25
Puckline Pick - New York Rangers, +1.5 (-200): C+
The puckline call starts with how these teams are losing: both on five-game skids, but the Flyers’ issues have tilted toward special teams and goaltending swings, while the Rangers’ blowouts sit alongside several games where they’ve coughed up leads and still hung around, a profile that often translates into one-goal results—especially with New York’s strong road record and their tendency to keep games close when they manage three or more goals. With Shesterkin and Fox unavailable, you don’t love paying -200 for the safety net, yet that same injury situation can push the Rangers into a more conservative, shot-blocking, road-style game, and their current forward group—Zibanejad, Panarin, J.T. Miller, Trocheck, Lafrenière—still has enough firepower and historical success against Philadelphia to answer back when Konecny and friends get rolling. The December 5-4 Rangers shootout win, plus a long run of high-scoring but tight meetings in this rivalry, hints that even when the Flyers have the better of play, they often don’t separate on the scoreboard, and the stakes around Metro positioning past midseason should keep both benches shortening the rotation late rather than chasing a blowout empty-net cover. I prefer the Flyers moneyline for the win, but if you expect another wild, special-teams-driven game that comes down to a late bounce or shootout, Rangers +1.5 at -200 is a defensible correlated angle, just one I’d only grade at C+ because of the steep price and the real risk that New York’s battered defense has one more collapse in it. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 17/01/2026 09:25
Get the best odds on this prediction
Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks
Related posts
Check out the latest picks from Shurzy AI and our team of experts.
