NHL

Islanders vs Panthers

Ilya Sorokin's road heater collides with Florida's desperate home push.

New York Islanders

NYI (15-10-3) VS FLA (12-12-2)

December 7, 2025 | 5:00 PM ET | Amerant Bank Arena, Sunrise, FL

Florida Panthers
Moneyline Pick - New York Islanders (+140): B+

With the Islanders on a three-game surge powered by Ilya Sorokin’s elite form and back-to-back wins over Tampa plus a statement 6-3 victory that snapped Colorado’s 17-game point streak, taking New York at +140 against a Florida team that just ended a four-game slide looks like the plus-money side with the better recent profile. Florida still has considerable home-ice bite and secondary scoring, as Saturday’s seven-goal outburst showed, but the absence of Aleksander Barkov and Matthew Tkachuk removes two of their best matchup drivers and leaves more of the heavy lifting to Carter Verhaeghe and Sam Bennett, while the Isles’ current injury slate is lighter, even with Kyle Palmieri sidelined. Verhaeghe’s earlier hat trick against New York this calendar year is a real concern, yet Sorokin’s current shutout heater and an Islanders group that’s defending more cohesively — combined with both clubs playing the second leg of a back-to-back and Florida’s recent tendency to trade chances — tilt me toward the underdog having closer to coin-flip win equity than the market implies. I grade Islanders +140 as a B+ pick: solid edge with meaningful upside, but not quite A-level due to Florida’s still-deep top nine and the Panthers’ rest and travel advantages (earlier home puck drop and no flight versus New York’s short hop from Tampa). Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 07/12/2025 09:25am

Over/Under Pick - Over 6 (-120): B

The total of 6 feels aggressively shaded after Sorokin’s recent shutout run, but Florida’s current game environment and personnel point me toward Over 6 (-120), even allowing for his ability to steal one. The Panthers just played a 7-6 track meet where their defensive zone coverage and Bobrovsky’s rebound control again wobbled, and without Barkov’s two-way stabilizing presence or Tkachuk’s heavy cycle game to pin teams in, they’ve leaned more on trading rush chances with Verhaeghe, Bennett and Marchand driving offense, especially at home. On the other side, New York’s attack has quietly ramped up with Barzal back producing, Horvat finishing, and depth like Calum Ritchie chipping in, and this is also a back-to-back spot for both teams with travel only on the Islanders’ side — a setup that often erodes structure as legs fade in the second half of the game. Add in the recent high-scoring head-to-head in Sunrise earlier this year where Verhaeghe torched the Isles for a hat trick, and it’s easier to envision a 4-3 type script than another Sorokin whitewash, though his ceiling keeps this from a top-shelf rating. I give Over 6 (-120) a B: a reasonable combination of likelihood and payout in a matchup tilted toward loose, chance-trading hockey, but dinged slightly by the risk that Sorokin simply suffocates Florida’s offense again. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 07/12/2025 09:25am

Puckline Pick - New York Islanders, +1.5 (-190): B-

Given Florida’s injuries up front, their recent stretch of one-goal decisions before the Columbus shootout, and the way Sorokin is dragging New York into every game right now, Islanders +1.5 at -190 stands out as the safer but less lucrative way to back the road side in what profiles as a tight contest. The Panthers still have enough scoring pop with Verhaeghe, Bennett, Marchand and a deep supporting cast to edge a result at home, especially with a modest rest edge and no travel after Saturday’s matinee, yet without Barkov and Tkachuk they’re less equipped to consistently blow teams out, and their defensive looseness has repeatedly let opponents hang around. New York’s own lineup, confirmed on ESPN’s current roster page, remains structurally sound down the middle with Barzal and Horvat, and even with Palmieri’s absence thinning the right side they’ve just held Colorado and Tampa in check during their three-game streak, suggesting they can keep this inside a one-goal margin even if they don’t win outright. Because of the steep price and the inherent volatility of an offense-first Florida team that can occasionally run away with a night, I grade Islanders +1.5 (-190) as a B-: high probability of cashing but limited monetary value compared with the moneyline, better suited to parlays or risk-averse bettors than as a standalone cornerstone. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 07/12/2025 09:25am

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks