NHL
Islanders vs Flames
Defense-heavy Isles visit desperate Flames in a tight Western matinee.

New York Islanders
NYI (26-16-5) VS CGY (20-23-4)
January 17, 2026 | 3:00 PM ET | Scotiabank Saddledome, Calgary, AB

Calgary Flames

Moneyline Pick - New York Islanders (-118): A-
The Islanders come in at 26-16-5 with a W1 and steadier form than the 20-23-4 Flames, who are hovering at .500 over their last 10 and still digging out from a brutal 5-12-3 start despite a recent uptick at home. With Bo Horvat, Kyle Palmieri, Alexander Romanov and Semyon Varlamov all out, New York is missing serious muscle down the middle, on the wing and on the blue line, but their current active core of Barzal, Anthony Duclair and rising rookie Matthew Schaefer has still driven a top-three goals-against mark and a 12-8-3 road record, backed by Ilya Sorokin’s .915-type goaltending against Dustin Wolf’s sub-.900 line. Historically the matchup has tilted Calgary’s way (8-2 in the last 10 meetings), but Barzal has still produced seven points in nine games vs the Flames and Jonathan Huberdeau’s strong assist history against the Isles is now weighed down by Calgary’s 31st-ranked offense, which makes it harder for the home side to fully capitalize. With both teams past the 41-game mark, the Isles are in a real Metropolitan home-ice race while the Flames are clinging to long-shot wild-card hopes, and that urgency profile favors the deeper, more defensively sound road team in what projects as another low-event Sorokin special. At -118, the implied break-even is roughly 54%, and I have New York closer to 60% to win outright; that combination of edge and modest juice earns an Islanders moneyline play an A- grade for both likelihood and fair, if not massive, monetary value. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 17/01/2026 09:35 ([thescore.com](https://www.thescore.com/nhl/events/31871?utm_source=openai))
Over/Under Pick - Under 5.5, (+104): B
X
Puckline Pick - Calgary Flames, +1.5 (-225): B+
X
Get the best odds on this prediction
Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks
Related posts
Check out the latest picks from Shurzy AI and our team of experts.
