NHL
Panthers vs Stars
Stars’ power play versus shorthanded champs: can Florida keep it close in Big D?

Florida Panthers
FLA (15-13-2) VS DAL (21-6-5)
December 13, 2025 | 8:00 p.m. ET | American Airlines Center, Dallas, Texas

Dallas Stars

Moneyline Pick - Dallas Stars (-145): A-
With Dallas riding a four-game home winning streak and an 8-1-1 surge over its last 10, the Stars moneyline at -145 looks justified against a Panthers team that has gone 4-5-1 over that same span and is only 5-7-0 on the road. The current ESPN rosters and game notes confirm Florida remains without Matthew Tkachuk, which leaves more of the offensive burden on Brad Marchand, Carter Verhaeghe, and Aleksander Barkov, while Dallas is missing Tyler Seguin but still rolls out an elite forward core led by Jason Robertson, Mikko Rantanen, Roope Hintz, and Wyatt Johnston. The Stars’ 33% power play meets a Panthers penalty kill hovering just above league average, and Dallas has been lethal when it gets even a single power-play goal, while Florida’s defensive metrics have slipped during a recent stretch that included a 7-6 track meet against Columbus and a 6-2 loss in Colorado. The Panthers did take the first meeting 4-3 in a shootout behind a Marchand two-goal night, which slightly tempers confidence, but home-ice advantage, superior special teams, and current form tilt this rematch toward Dallas; at -145, the price combines solid win probability with reasonable risk for an A- grade on the moneyline. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 13/12/2025 09:56
Over/Under Pick - Over 5.5 (-135): B+
The 5.5 total leans Over at -135, and there are several indicators that support a higher-scoring game despite two capable goaltending groups: Dallas is averaging north of 3.3 goals per game with one of the league’s most efficient power plays, while Florida sits just over 3.1 goals per night but has seen its defensive structure wobble recently, allowing 6 to Colorado and 6 to Columbus in that wild overtime win. The first matchup finished 4-3 in a shootout, and the same cast of drivers is in place from the current ESPN rosters—Marchand, Verhaeghe, Barkov, and Anton Lundell for Florida; Robertson, Rantanen, and Johnston for Dallas—so there’s little reason to expect a low-event slog, especially with the Stars’ man-advantage likely to pressure a Panthers penalty kill that has been good rather than dominant. Dallas’ strong 10-4-1 home mark and four-game home streak have come largely on the back of multi-goal outputs, while Florida tends to either trade chances or lean on late offense when chasing, both of which favor the Over; the only hesitation is the potential for Sergei Bobrovsky or Casey DeSmith to steal a lower-scoring result, and that goaltending ceiling plus the heavy juice keeps this as a B+ rather than an A pick on Over 5.5. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 13/12/2025 09:56
Puckline Pick - Florida Panthers, +1.5 (-210): B
Even while leaning Dallas on the moneyline, the puckline value pushes slightly toward Florida +1.5 at -210, as the Panthers have already shown they can hang with this Stars roster by taking a 4-3 shootout win in the first meeting and still dress a high-end spine—Barkov, Marchand, Lundell, Verhaeghe—despite Tkachuk’s absence. Dallas has been outstanding overall and especially at home, but their style and recent results often skew toward one- or two-goal margins rather than consistent blowouts, and the current injury report (Tyler Seguin and multiple depth defenders out) slightly trims their ability to roll four lines and suffocate games late. Florida’s recent stretch has been volatile, yet it includes statement wins over the Islanders and that wild comeback against Columbus, indicating they can generate enough offense to stay inside a one-goal window even when outplayed territorially, and Bobrovsky’s track record suggests he can at least keep the scoreline tight if Dallas’ power play doesn’t completely take over. Because the price on +1.5 is steep at -210 and offers limited monetary upside relative to the risk of an empty-net cover for the Stars, this lands as a B-grade recommendation: a solid, but not elite, way to back the champs to keep it within a goal in Big D. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 13/12/2025 09:56
Get the best odds on this prediction
Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks
Related posts
Check out the latest picks from Shurzy AI and our team of experts.

