NHL

Panthers vs Sabres

Buffalo’s surge collides with a wounded Florida dynasty in a midseason measuring stick.

Florida Panthers

FLA (23-18-3) VS BUF (24-15-4)

January 12, 2026 | 7:00 PM ET | KeyBank Center, Buffalo, NY

Buffalo Sabres
Moneyline Pick - Buffalo Sabres (-118): B
Buffalo’s top line, led by Tage Thompson, comes in scorching with the Sabres having won 13 of their last 14 and riding a fresh three-game streak, while Florida has stumbled to a 2-3-0 mark over its last five despite that statement win over Colorado and now heads into another hostile building on this six-game trip. The Sabres’ current roster core of Thompson, Alex Tuch and a confident Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen is intact, whereas Florida’s active group is missing key pieces like Seth Jones on the blue line and still awaiting Matthew Tkachuk’s return, with Brad Marchand also banged up recently, leaving the defending champs far from full strength. Historically, Thompson has produced steadily against the Panthers and Marchand has torched Buffalo over his career, but with Marchand less than 100% and Tkachuk likely not yet back, Buffalo’s offensive form plus its strong home record and secure playoff positioning in the East stack up better than a Florida side currently sitting outside the playoff cutline. At -118 the Sabres aren’t cheap, but given their form, health advantage relative to Florida’s stars, and the chance to create more separation in the Atlantic around the halfway point, this is a reasonable value play at a B-grade confidence level. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 12/01/2026 09:23
Over/Under Pick - Under 6.5, (-125): B-
Buffalo’s recent box scores scream offense with three straight five-goal outings, but zooming out to full-season profiles and context makes the Under 6.5 more attractive than it first looks, especially with Florida’s attack likely capped by injuries and absences among its top forwards. The Sabres’ underlying numbers show them allowing just over three goals per game with an elite penalty kill, while Florida’s current roster has been grinding out lower-scoring results more often than not, including four Unders in its last six and just 1.8 goals per game over its last five heading into this trip. Add in that this is a midseason, playoff-positioning kind of divisional game—Buffalo trying to solidify a top-half Eastern seed, Florida desperate simply to stay in the chase after 44 games—and you’re more likely to get tightened defensive structure, heavier usage of top pairings, and fewer risks late if one side has a narrow lead. Goaltending form for Buffalo has quietly stabilized and Florida’s recent win over Colorado showed it can still drag a high-powered opponent into a grinding 2-1 type game, which all nudges this toward a slightly juiced Under 6.5 at a B- grade given the Sabres’ recent scoring heater adding some volatility. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 12/01/2026 09:23
Puckline Pick - Buffalo Sabres, -1.5 (+220): C+
With Buffalo covering the number frequently during this 13–1 surge and already owning a 3-0 shutout of Florida earlier in the season, the Sabres -1.5 at +220 is an enticing but high-variance way to back the hotter, healthier side in front of a home crowd that’s starting to smell a real playoff push. Florida’s active roster is stretched: Seth Jones is out, Matthew Tkachuk has yet to debut this year and may still be a game or two away, and Brad Marchand has been managing an undisclosed issue, all of which contribute to a negative goal differential on the season and several recent multi-goal defeats including that 4-1 loss in Toronto. Buffalo, by contrast, has been winning by margin behind deep scoring—Quinn, Tuch, Josh Doan and others chipping in—and a tandem of Luukkonen and Colten Ellis that has allowed the Sabres to tilt games territorially, especially at KeyBank Center where they’ve posted strong multi-goal results in this run. Given Florida’s championship pedigree and the chance that Sergei Bobrovsky can steal a tight one, laying -1.5 is still just a C+ grade play, but the plus-money price is justified by current form, home dominance, and a matchup that has recently tilted toward Buffalo blowouts more than coin-flip finishes. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 12/01/2026 09:23
Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks