NHL

Stars vs Sharks

Can Dallas’ road machine survive San Jose’s Celebrini-fueled surge?

Dallas Stars

DAL (22-7-5) VS SJS (17-14-3)

December 18, 2025 | 10:00 PM ET | SAP Center at San Jose, San Jose, CA

San Jose Sharks
Moneyline Pick - Dallas Stars (-220): A-

With Dallas 11-2-4 on the road and 7-2-1 in its last 10, the Stars’ moneyline edge rests on a deeper, healthier core than San Jose can dress despite the Sharks’ three-game winning streak and recent offensive spike. San Jose is suddenly dangerous at home behind Macklin Celebrini’s heater and Tyler Toffoli’s finishing, but they’re down Will Smith and Philipp Kurashev up front, while Dallas is missing Tyler Seguin yet has reinserted Matt Duchene and Jamie Benn around a still-loaded top six with Jason Robertson, Roope Hintz, and Joe Pavelski. Dallas already handled this matchup 4-1 earlier this month, and their special teams gap plus superior blue-line depth in front of Jake Oettinger/Casey DeSmith should tilt the five-on-five and special-teams shot share enough to justify laying the price despite the Sharks’ improved push. The number is rich, but in a spot where Dallas is chasing top seeding and San Jose is overachieving on a thin roster, Stars -220 grades as an A- confidence play, strong for parlays or as a moneyline anchor rather than a straight heavy stake. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 18/12/2025 09:54am

Over/Under Pick - Over 6 (-110): B

The first meeting finished 4-1, but the context has shifted: the Sharks have piled up three straight wins while scoring 17 goals in that span, with Celebrini driving play, John Klingberg jumping into the rush, and Yaroslav Askarov still more “promising” than proven behind a defense missing key two-way forwards like Smith and Kurashev. Dallas arrives with one of the league’s most efficient power plays and plenty of depth scoring (Robertson, Hintz, Pavelski, Duchene, Jamie Benn, Wyatt Johnston), and even with Seguin sidelined, this group usually pushes tempo on the road and punishes teams that take penalties, an area where San Jose can still wobble. The Stars’ blue line can suppress chances, but on the second night before a back-to-back swing and facing a confident Sharks top six, it’s reasonable to expect both sides to get to three often enough that a seventh goal decides things. With recent offensive form on both benches and some defensive fragility still baked into San Jose’s profile, Over 6 at -110 earns a solid but variance-sensitive B grade. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 18/12/2025 09:54am

Puckline Pick - Dallas Stars, -1.5 (118): B+

Even with San Jose 10-5-3 at home and riding a three-game heater, Dallas has already demonstrated the matchup ceiling in a 4-1 win earlier this month, and their road profile suggests a clear gap that often translates into multi-goal victories when they get the first one. The Stars’ forward depth remains superior despite Seguin’s injury, and their power play plus transition game can stretch a Sharks defense that still bleeds rush chances and is missing Smith and Kurashev, forcing more minutes onto secondary forwards while Celebrini, Toffoli, and Goodrow shoulder heavy offensive usage. Dallas’ blue line and goaltending combination has a higher floor than San Jose’s, and if they play from ahead, the Sharks’ need to open up for offense invites the empty-net scenario that historically turns tight games into puckline covers for favorites like the Stars. With plus-money attached to a path that lines up with Dallas’ typical win script—special-teams edge, territorial advantage, and late insurance—Stars -1.5 at 118 grades out as a B+ value play, slightly riskier than the moneyline but offering a more attractive payout for a similar game story. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 18/12/2025 09:54am

Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks