NHL

Sabres vs Stars

Hot Sabres collide with battle-tested Stars in a New Year’s litmus test.

Buffalo Sabres

BUF (20-14-4) VS DAL (25-7-7)

December 31, 2025 | 8:00 PM ET | American Airlines Center, Dallas, TX

Dallas Stars
Moneyline Pick - Dallas Stars (-160): B+
Buffalo’s nine-game heater and 3.08 goals per game make them a terrifying visitor, but their 8-9-2 road mark, a banged-up depth chart that includes Jason Zucker and multiple goalies on the injury report, and a heavy recent workload tilt this spot toward a rested, deep Dallas team that has gone 3-0-2 in its last five and owns a 12-5-2 record at American Airlines Center with a 3.49 GF/G and 2.62 GAA profile built on Jake Oettinger and Casey DeSmith. Dallas also brings a significant special-teams edge (power play pushing above 30%) and has already shown in last year’s New Year’s Eve matchup that its top-end skill—Jason Robertson, Mikko Rantanen, Wyatt Johnston—can solve Buffalo’s structure in key moments, while the Sabres’ surge has them climbing the Atlantic but still short of the schedule’s halfway mark, meaning this is as much a measuring stick as a must-win for their playoff push. With home-ice advantage, superior goaltending metrics, and more proven scoring depth against a Sabres side that’s due for some regression after a stretch of tight, lower-scoring wins, I’m laying the price on the Stars moneyline at -160 and grading it a B+ for a solid but not elite combination of win probability and return. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 31/12/2025 09:32
Over/Under Pick - Over 6, (-120): B
The total of 6 feels like a key pivot point in a matchup where Buffalo has quietly tightened up during its streak (recent finals like 4-2, 4-1, 3-2, 3-1, 3-2) but still carries enough finishing talent with Tage Thompson and Alex Tuch to capitalize if this turns into a special-teams contest, while Dallas has been involved in much higher-event games lately—scorelines of 4-3, 4-3, 5-1, 8-3, and 5-3—driven by an elite power play near 30% and a deep top six led by Robertson and Rantanen. The Stars’ ability to finish their chances against aggressive, up-tempo opponents, combined with Buffalo’s recent offensive form and a Sabres blue line missing pieces and nursing a day-to-day starting goalie, suggests a good chance we see both teams reach at least two or three goals despite respectable season-long GAAs, especially with New Year’s Eve energy, playoff-race stakes, and tired penalty-kill units after tough December schedules all nudging this toward a game where one push of momentum could blow the lid off the total. I’ll lean to Over 6 at -120 and grade it a B: the offensive firepower and special-teams profiles justify the play, but Buffalo’s recent under-friendly results and potential goaltending strength cap the value a bit. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 31/12/2025 09:32
Puckline Pick - Buffalo Sabres, +1.5 (-190): A-
Even while I like Dallas to win the game, Buffalo catching +1.5 on the puckline at -190 is extremely appealing given how they’ve played during this nine-game run, with only one of those victories decided by more than two goals and a defensive structure that has held recent opponents like Boston and St. Louis to two or fewer while riding a confident tandem of Alex Lyon and Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen when healthy. Dallas has certainly shown it can blow teams out—their last three wins all came by at least two goals—but the Stars now face a Sabres group that is defending with playoff urgency, sits firmly in the Atlantic playoff chase, and can roll multiple scoring threats (Thompson, Tuch, Jack Quinn, Zach Benson) even with Zucker sidelined, making a one-goal game a very live outcome in a building where Buffalo already hung around before falling 4-2 last New Year’s Eve. With the Stars coming off back-to-back extra-time losses and the Sabres in rhythm at five-on-five, I expect Dallas’s edge to show up more in a narrow moneyline result than in a multi-goal romp, so I’m taking Buffalo +1.5 and grading it an A-: the payout is modest at this juice, but the probability of the Sabres keeping it within a goal is high enough to make this my favorite value angle on the board. Odds and availability are subject to change. This bet was made at 31/12/2025 09:32
Share this post

Get the best odds on this prediction

Use our Live Odds Tool to get the best price on your favourite picks